If you think frames are bad now, wait until you read this little nugget from 10 years ago.
Frames break the unified model of the Web and introduce a new way of looking at data that has not been well integrated into the other aspects of the Web. With frames, the user’s view of information on the screen is now determined by a sequence of navigation actions rather than a single navigation action. Navigation does not work with frames since the unit of navigation is different from the unit of view. If users create a bookmark in their browser they may not get the same view back when they follow the bookmark at a later date since the bookmark doesn’t include a representation of the state of the frames on the page. Even worse, URLs stop working: the addressing information shown at the top of the browser no longer constitutes a complete specification of the information shown in the window. If an author copies the URL in order to include it as a hypertext anchor in one of his or her own pages then that anchor will not lead readers to the desired view but to the initial state of the frameset. Similarly, if a user decides to send an email message to a friend with the recommendation to check out a page, then copying the URL from the browser will not work if frames are used since the URL points to the frameset and not to the current view (with the information of interest to the friend). Given that social filtering is one of the most powerful mechanisms for information discovery on the Internet, it is an utter disaster to disable the URL as an addressing mechanism.
I think I’ve discussed this before. It’s just funny to read something like this that was written 10 years ago. And, yes, frames were bad back then too.
[ Why Frames Suck (Most of the time) ] useit.com
6 Responses to “Webtrends circa ‘96”
Leave a Reply
Comment moderation in full effect!
All comments at donburnside.com are moderated by my first rate team of robot warriors, ready to do battle with all the nare-do-wells that stalk the interwebs!
Besides, it's only your first comment (per IP address if you are commenting from work and home) that the robot warriors have to approve. After that it should be clear saling! If not, contact db and I'm sure he'll hook you up.
Finally, for those of you in the know, Markdown is available as it a very small set of HTML tags. If you are scratching your head, don't worry, it's just geek stuff. You can still comment!
Thanks for stopping by!
March 18th, 2007 at 6:47 am
I oughtta fire up eWorld on my Performa and check these “frames” as you call them out.
March 18th, 2007 at 7:59 am
eWorld? Was that before or after AOL v4.0?
March 18th, 2007 at 9:15 am
eWorld was between ‘94 and ‘96.
March 18th, 2007 at 9:28 am
Ah yes eWorld. The original AOL.
March 18th, 2007 at 9:30 am
yes, of course!
March 19th, 2007 at 4:22 am
Remember the microsoft network- internet via opening folders ala explorer style?